← Auto Edge Sample report · this is the exact format your store receives. Names and dealership are fictional.
AUTOEDGE Sample Report
Internet Lead Mystery Shop
10-Day Response & Cadence Evaluation
72
Total Score
B− · Solid, Fixable
Dealership
Northpoint Ford (sample)
Vehicle of Interest
2026 Ford F-150 STX
First Response Time
1 minute
Reps Involved
Marcus, Dana
Evaluation Window
10 days
Score Breakdown
⚡ Initial Response Quality
34 / 40
📅 Human Effort & Cadence
24 / 40
💎 Message Quality & Appointment Ask
14 / 20

Initial Lead Response · Off the Line

Day 0
EventTimeChannelRep
Lead receivedFeb 16, 1:52 p.m.Web formn/a
Phone callFeb 16, 1:52 p.m.VoicemailMarcus
Text messageFeb 16, 1:54 p.m.SMSMarcus
EmailFeb 16, 1:54 p.m.EmailMarcus
EmailFeb 16, 1:56 p.m.EmailDana
Text messageFeb 16, 1:57 p.m.SMSDana
Text message (video)Feb 16, 2:04 p.m.SMSMarcus

Strong Off the Line

Response time was exceptional, under one minute from submission, well above industry standard. The voicemail and text follow-up were strong, and the personalized video shows a clear understanding of modern customer engagement. Even with the video link no longer active, the effort itself reflects high initiative and good instincts.

Too Much Gas, Too Early

All follow-up happened inside a 10 to 12 minute window, with six attempts almost immediately after the lead arrived. The hustle is appreciated, but it risks overwhelming the customer and burning the opportunity too fast. After that burst, nothing else went out the rest of the day, leaving the timeline underused. The video also arrived as a bare micro-URL with no explanation, which can read like spam.

Pace the Drive

The energy and speed are excellent; the opportunity is in pacing. Spread attempts across the day and the days that follow to keep the conversation alive without crowding the customer. When sending a video, introduce it in the text so the customer knows what the link is before clicking. With a slightly more measured cadence, this approach converts at a very high level.

🔭

Pit Stop · The First 3 Days

Days 1–3
EventTimeChannelRep
Text messageFeb 17, 8:56 a.m.SMSMarcus
Phone callFeb 17, 10:26 a.m.VoicemailMarcus
EmailFeb 18, 2:13 p.m.EmailDana
Text messageFeb 18, 2:14 p.m.SMSDana

Solid Structure, Good Features

The digital follow-up structure is strong. The email cadence is well written and clearly works to move the customer toward an appointment. An organized process is in place, with the right intentions and a system built to keep opportunities moving.

Lost Momentum After the Launch

The first 72 hours are the most important, and after a strong start, momentum slowed quickly. Only one call went out on day two, and none on day three. On top of that, two different team members reached out by text and email, which can confuse the customer about who they are actually working with.

Keep the Engine Running

Focus call activity on drive-time windows in those first three days, when customers are most reachable. Steady attempts in that window preserve the momentum from day one. Assign a single point of contact to avoid mixed signals and create a clearer, more personal experience. A little more structure in the first 72 hours lifts this whole process.

🏁

Finish Line · The 10-Day Process

Days 4–10
EventTimeChannelRep
Email + TextFeb 19, 2:13 p.m.Email / SMSDana
Email + TextFeb 20, 3:52 p.m.Email / SMSMarcus
Text messageFeb 21, 8:56 a.m.SMSMarcus
Text messageFeb 22, 2:14 p.m.SMSDana
Call + Text + EmailFeb 23, 1:32 p.m.MultiMarcus
Text messageFeb 24, 1:51 p.m.SMSMarcus
Text messageFeb 26, 8:57 a.m.SMSMarcus

Strong Driver Behind the Wheel

The process started strong and the rep showed excellent initiative, personalizing messages, adjusting texts, and working in real "why-buy" reasons to engage. The follow-up systems are clearly in place, and the effort on this lead reflects a store that takes opportunities seriously in 2026.

Too Much Automation, Not Enough Calls

From day 1 through day 10, only four calls were placed. The first 72 hours are the critical window and call volume there should be much higher. The automated workflow also began mirroring the same message across email and text, which quickly feels robotic and dilutes the rep's personal outreach. Videos again went out as micro-URLs with no setup, which looks suspicious to a customer.

Balance the Engine and the Automation

Calls need to carry more of the load: a good baseline is two attempts a day for the first three days, spaced at commute hours and evening availability, spread out rather than clustered. Slow the automated text cadence and let the salesperson lead real communication. From day 4 to day 10, shift the messaging from repeated prompts to brand storytelling, why your store. Always introduce a video link ("I recorded a quick 30-second walkaround of the truck you asked about") to build trust. It is also worth reviewing the rest of the team for the same patterns; in most stores, automation works best on overnight and post-day-10 re-engagement while the team owns live contact in the early window.

This is a sample. Want one for your store?

We will shop your store like a real customer and return this exact report, then review it live with your team.